LLI Wiki — My Digital Knowledge Base

SQL Server AlwaysOn: WSFC (Windows) or Pacemaker (Linux)

Comparison of an AlwaysOn cluster on Windows Server Failover Cluster and an AlwaysOn cluster on Pacemaker on Linux.

This table compares two ways of running SQL Server Availability Groups with a cluster manager: Windows Server Failover Cluster (WSFC) on Windows, and Pacemaker on Linux.

Comparison

Criterion SQL Server with WSFC (Windows) SQL Server with Pacemaker (Linux)
Platform Windows Linux
Native integration Yes. WSFC is natively integrated with Windows and SQL Server. No. Pacemaker requires specific configuration to work with SQL Server on Linux.
Configuration complexity Medium. WSFC is commonly used with SQL Server on Windows, so documentation and field experience are abundant. Higher. Combining SQL Server, Linux and Pacemaker can require specific expertise.
Active Directory dependency Yes. WSFC is generally tied to Active Directory for identity, rights and cluster objects. If the servers are joined to an existing AD domain, DNS names and servers use the domain FQDN and must be able to reach the domain controllers. No. Pacemaker does not require AD, although Linux can be integrated with AD if needed.
Management and monitoring tools Windows-based tools and consoles, such as the MMC (Microsoft Management Console). Linux-based tools for management and monitoring.
Platform flexibility Limited to Windows. More flexible, with a choice of Linux distribution and configuration.
Cost Windows and SQL Server licences can increase costs. Depending on the Linux distribution chosen, operating system costs may be lower, but SQL Server costs remain.
Support and resources Broad support, large community and official Microsoft resources. Less common than WSFC, but supported. Documentation may be less abundant.
Performance Solid and well-documented performance. Performance depends on the Linux distribution and configuration. In some cases there can be advantages.

Choosing

This table is a simplified overview. The best choice depends on the organisation's requirements, the team's skills, the budget and other factors.

Mastodon LLIMastodon SocialFosstodon